The Cleveland Guardians have had a strong start to the 2024 season, boasting a 12-6 record in their first 18 games. However, the team is experiencing a shift in their usual approach to success. Known for their pitching prowess, the Guardians have surprised by delivering impressive offensive performances, while their starting pitching has encountered challenges.
The loss of ace Shane Bieber to Tommy John surgery was a significant setback. Bieber had performed exceptionally well in his two starts before it was revealed that he had suffered an elbow injury. With Bieber sidelined, the Guardians are now looking to Triston McKenzie to step up and lead the rotation.
McKenzie, a 26-year-old with immense potential, has faced injury issues throughout his career. Despite showing glimpses of being a top-tier pitcher when healthy, McKenzie has struggled in the 2024 season. Some speculate whether his underperformance may be linked to a lingering injury, especially considering his decision to decline Tommy John surgery last year.
According to a report from Zack Meisel and Jason Lloyd of The Athletic, McKenzie opted for “rest and rehab” over surgery. While undergoing Tommy John surgery typically entails a lengthy recovery period of at least a year, McKenzie was determined to return to the Guardians’ rotation as quickly as possible without going under the knife.
Reflecting on his decision from last year, McKenzie recently shared his thoughts via The Athletic, expressing uncertainty about whether he made the right choice. Despite the doubts, he currently feels physically well and stands by his decision.
Triston McKenzie’s 2024 season with Guardians
McKenzie had an impressive debut season in the major leagues in 2020, but faced setbacks in 2021 before experiencing a breakout performance in 2022.
In 2023, McKenzie’s appearances were limited to just four games due to the aforementioned injuries, coinciding with his need to make the critical decision about Tommy John surgery.
While McKenzie’s choice garnered respect from teammates and fans, his performance in 2024 has been lackluster thus far, with a 6.23 ERA across three starts spanning 13 innings. However, it’s essential to recognize the small sample size and the potential for improvement as the season progresses.
Nevertheless, McKenzie’s decision regarding Tommy John surgery has sparked discussions. Opting against the surgery carries inherent risks, but McKenzie addressed the fear surrounding potential injury concerns, acknowledging that injuries are sometimes unavoidable in the game.
With Shane Bieber sidelined, the 26-year-old McKenzie is now the eldest pitcher in Cleveland’s rotation apart from veteran Carlos Carrasco. Carrasco’s experience will be invaluable for the Guardians, but there is hope that McKenzie can emerge as the team’s ace.
Looking ahead, McKenzie’s performance could have long-term implications for the Guardians. With Bieber set to become a free agent after the season, McKenzie may be in line to take the mound on Opening Day in 2025 if he can rebound and perform well this season.
